Topic " Should we introduce sales tax system?"
Agree side: Alex and Anna
Disagree side: Rie, Rachel and Amy(I)
Rie
He thought it's not fair for less income people to pay sales tax because sales tax is equal to everyone. And the income tax is better than sales tax because income tax is
Rachel
She also disagreed with this topic and there are both the rich and poor. And we can't distinguish whether the rich or poor when we went shopping. Even if the sales tax rate depends on the income, we can't find low income or high income.
Amy (I)
I thought inspite of not changing our income, if we introduce it, we'll come not to buy many things and Apollon's economy may decline. Besides, as a doctor, we people who work at the hospital need to buy big medical instruments. They cost a lot of money without sales tax.
Anna
She thought sales tax system can gather a lot of money from everyone easily. And we can use the money for Sunflower festival.
Alex
Her son will enter the elementary school and if sales tax system is introduced, they don't have to cost a lot of money for education fee.
<Question>
Q: What do you think about sales tax's unfairness?
A: We should separate the tax rate between the rich and the poor by showing their income something like paper.
Q:In spite of not changing our income, we have to pay more money. What do you think about it?
A: I agree, but we have a lot of national debt and we have to pay more money.
Q: What percent of sales tax do you want to decide?
A: 3%
Q:What kind of taxes are in Apollon now?
A: Excepting for sales tax and income tax. For example, resident's tax.
<Conclusion>
We couldn' decide whether we introduce income tax or sales tax. But if we introduce sales tax, we'll set 3%.
In fact, I couldn't understand same side panelist's idea, so I couldn't support it. Besides, I couldn't express my opinion clearly and qustioned other panelists because of my shyness. It was very bad point of me, so I want to change myself. The moderator Kate summarized everyone's idea and worked hard. I want to be the panelist who can support the moderator next time!
Amy, I'm sorry for not having shared my idea with you and Rachel. Before I stated it toward audience, I should have cooperated with same side more. Next time, let's talk about the idea as a same side a lot.
返信削除I think you had a many good opinions, so I want to listen to you more next time. I also hesitate to state my opinion, let's do our best!!
返信削除I'm really sorry I asked you for help many many times although you were one of the panelists. Now, I can understand it is unfair because help from disagree side was not fit for another side!
返信削除You had some good opinions, so I wanted to listen to your opinions more. The discussion was also difficult for me to understand. I expect you can say your ideas next time.
返信削除You could say your opiunions clearly. So, I think you are good. I hope you can do as well as this time in the final discussion.
返信削除It was good that you considered this topic from viewpoint of your career, and your opinion was easy to understand.
返信削除Your opinion was creaky and easy to understand. So, it's better if you have your opinions more.
返信削除It was easy to understand what you said, good!
返信削除But I want you to speak more positively, you should have confidence!!!
Your opinioin was very clearly, and I could understand well.
返信削除Your opinion was understandable, and the reason was clear. So, you will speak more in the next disccusion, it will be better.
返信削除You didn't speak much. When you cannot understand other's opinion, you should ask them! Your English was very simple, so I want you to speak more.
返信削除I think your question was so good because it was understandable.
返信削除You had good opinions so you should have more confidence.
返信削除You are doctor so I thought you say that we need to introduce sales tax system for medical care. However you had a different opinions so it's very interesting.
返信削除Your opinions were understanble, so have a confident!!
返信削除You always have good ideas, but I wanted to know the reason in detail our income would not increase.
返信削除Your opinion was easy to understand. I think it was good opinion about economic of Apollon.
返信削除