Tenth discussion

Topic "We should prohibit students from working part-time jobs."

Agree side: Finnian, Hanna and Kofy
Disagree side: Lucus and Allie

Finnian
She agreed with this topic because students should concentrate on studying and club activity. They can do part-time jobs after graduating school. And if they get money, they may use them to hang out with their friends. She worried about these points.

Hanna
She also agreed with it. Studying is the most important thing for students. If they are allowed to do part-time job, they come not to go to school and study. Besides, they can get money by themselves and they come not to obey their parents.

Kofy
She also agreed with it. She thought reading books is very important and it makes student's sensitivity rich. Besides, they can get knowledge from books. So making reading time is more important than doing part-time jobs.

Lucus
Now, he can't go to school because of not having so much money. If we prohibit it, students who don't have money like him can't get money to go to school.

Allie
She also disagreed with it. By doing part-time jobs, they can learn importance of money and grow to responsibility. Besides, if they work outside, they can make a lot of friends.


Carol: What do you think about Lucus's opinion? (to agree side members)
Finnian: Poor students like Lucus are rare. Anyway, I'm worrying that children want to get to hang out with thier friends.
Lucus: Parents should manage the money.

Kofy: I think doing part-time jobs can reduce the time to study or read books.
Lucus: I think it's same as doing club activity.

Hanna: What's the purpose of doing part-time jobs?
Lucus: I don't think they "should" do part-time jobs.
Allie: If they do it, they can help family's income.

<From audience>
Mac: There are many children who don't have so much money. Does our government support them?
Carol: No, now there is no support from government.

Sophie: Agree side said that they worried about the time to study, but students who can't go to school can't study at all.
Hanna: The government should support them.

Emily: Many high school students want to work after graduating school. So part-time job is good for them. What do you think?
Finnian: They have to study hard for job hunting.

Robbert: Now, I deliver newspaper as a part-time job in the morning.
Kofy: We should focus on juniot high school students.

Carol: Let's decide the time they can work.
Finnian: By 10 p.m because I want them to study.

Carol: Let's decide the type of jobs.
Hanna: Delivering newspaper is good, but restaurant which provide alcohol shouldn't be allowed.
Allie: Construction cite is danger.
Sophie: How about making part-time job club? If so, school can control and protect students.
Lucus: Do all schools make the club?
Finnian: School should choose part-time job first.
Hanna: All of ideas should be mixed.

<Couclusion>
Students have to get parent's and school's permission, and junior high school can make part-time jobs club and they can provide part-time jobs. Students can work before 10 p.m.

I think this discussion was very wonderful!!! Every members expressed their own ideas many times actively and listened to each other. Besides, the moderator, Carol, summarize their opinion every times and spoke fluently. And i think she was mutual. In next discussion of our group, I'll be the moderator, so I really want to follow Carol!! I also want to lead to good couclusion.